About Park Bake Shop

Tucked along Main Street in Kings Park, NY, Park Bake Shop is a beloved neighborhood gem where tradition, craftsmanship, and community come together in every bite. Since relocating to Kings Park in 2004, this Italian-American, kosher-certified bakery has earned a reputation for excellence—offering scratch-made pastries, breads, cookies, and custom cakes that keep locals and out-of-towners alike coming back for more.

Step inside, and you're immediately greeted by the comforting aroma of fresh semolina loaves, buttery croissants, and espresso pulled to perfection. Every item is baked on-site using real ingredients—no preservatives, no shortcuts—just classic recipes prepared with care. From jelly cronuts that spark early-morning lines to the beloved apple-cherry lattice pies, everything on the menu feels like a handmade treat from someone who knows their craft. On my recent visit, I sampled their semolina bread and a chocolate-covered brownie—both revealed the kind of texture and flavor that only come from scratch baking.

Beyond daily treats, Park Bake Shop also elevates life’s special moments with custom cakes that are as beautiful as they are delicious. Whether it’s a tiered wedding cake, a fun birthday design, or their signature cannoli cake—enthusiastically described by co-owner Gabe Shtanko as “OUTRAGEOUS”—their work shows both technical skill and artistic flair. It's no wonder locals trust them with their most cherished celebrations.

What makes Park Bake Shop truly special, though, is the people behind the counter. Owners Gabe and Lucy treat guests like family, offering warm greetings, helpful suggestions, and a genuine sense of welcome that resonates with regulars. With a 4.5-star rating on Tripadvisor and glowing reviews on multiple platforms, Park Bake Shop is more than just a bakery—it’s a community cornerstone.

So if you find yourself in Kings Park craving something sweet or meaningful, swing by 112 Main Street. Whether you’re grabbing coffee and a pastry or ordering a custom cake, you’ll leave with something memorable—made with skill, served with heart.

Restaurants Info

Popular Menu

  • Donuts

    $

  • Italian Cheesecake

    $

  • Doughnut

    $

  • Wedding Cake

    $

  • Chocolate Pudding Pie

    $

  • Carrot Cake Cream Cheese Frosting

    $

  • Pink Flower Cupcakes

    $

  • Confetti Cupcakes

    $
Check full menu

Business Info

Service options
Accessibility
Offerings
Dining options
Amenities
Planning
Payments
Parking

  • In-store pick-up

  • Takeaway

  • Delivery

  • Wheelchair-accessible car park

  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance

  • Coffee

  • Breakfast

  • Wi-Fi

  • Wi-Fi

  • Quick visit

  • Credit cards

  • Debit cards

  • NFC mobile payments

  • Credit cards

  • Free of charge street parking

  • Free parking lot

Image Not Found

Location & Contact

112 NY-25A, Kings Park, NY 11754, United States
Call Anytime : +1 631-269-3825

Opening Times

Right Now : Checking...

  • Monday :

    06:00 AM - 07:00 PM

  • Tuesday :

    06:00 AM - 07:00 PM

  • Wednesday :

    06:00 AM - 07:00 PM

  • Thursday :

    07:00 AM - 07:00 PM

  • Friday :

    06:00 AM - 07:00 PM

  • Saturday :

    06:00 AM - 07:00 PM

  • Sunday :

    06:00 AM - 06:00 PM
Image Not Found Image Not Found
Restaurants Info

Customers Feedback

(5/5)

“ Delicious desserts, many choices, good service, easy parking. People loved the desserts from here. ”

Margaret S.
(5/5)

“ I was happy to stop by a few weeks ago. I bought a delicious chocolate cake and the wonderful "cake angel" put happy birthday on it! It was a few days late but I figured I might as well celebrate! The crew (and kind customers) all wished me a great day! I told her how my aunt and uncle swore by the place and now I know why! It's a place I can be with wonderful people, delicious traditional cakes & feel the spirit of my aunt & uncle in their town any time I go! ”

Liz L.
(5/5)

“ A truly sumptuous experience-the staff is amazing! I always stop for goodies to bring to my mom when I visit her on Staten Island. ”

Susan H.
(4/5)

“ Most of the bakery product are fresh and delicious. There are a couple of standouts: apple/cherry lattice pie, chocolate covered brownies, and the jelly cronuts. All are delicious! The Sfogliatelles are hit or miss. This bakery shop sells reasonably priced baked goods and they have a selection for people who eat GF. The staff is friendly and efficient. ”

S R.
(4/5)

“ Nice neighborhood bake shop old school string machine for the white boxes. And AMAZING brownies. And super delicious Italian cookies. We will be back when in town YUM. I would have given "5" stars however the last 2 times the staff just looked at us and were not happy to be there. We had to ask who would like to take our order. However the treats are so good I guess there is no real reason to be friendly when taking the order. It may be a generational thing. LOL. ”

Mar B.
(5/5)

“ Couldn't stop eating the gluten free m&m chocolate chip cookies. I have celiac's disease it's hard to find cookies that taste THIS good ! Thanks park bake shop ”

Andrea F.
(5/5)

“ Our office got an apple crumb cheesecake and a platter of italian cookies and they were all amazing. The italian cookies were some of the best I have had on the island: soft, flavorful, fresh. The cheesecake was also incredible: so flavorful but not heavy at all. Highly recommend! ”

Annabelle L.
(5/5)

“ So my boyfriend is a huge pastry fanatic. He's Italian and this bakery matched all of his expectations!! Honestly I have to say delicious so fresh and yummy definitely worth it. ”

Michelle F.

Try These Spots

Baker's Dozen

Baker's Dozen

1307 Buck Jones Rd, Raleigh, NC 27606, United States

Baker & Commons

Baker & Commons

2900 College Ave, Berkeley, CA 94705, United States

Bagel Gourmet

Bagel Gourmet

9608, 162 S New York Rd, Galloway, NJ 08205, United States

Bagel Bistro

Bagel Bistro

173 US-1, Tequesta, FL 33469, United States

Bad Wolf Burgers

Bad Wolf Burgers

1401 N Forbes Rd, Lexington, KY 40511, United States